Comments on: Is Mineral Makeup Better for Your Skin?

By: Jessica Allison

Jessica Allison — Mon, 03 Oct 2011 18:42:25 +0000

I have heard this about the ingredient bismuth oxychloride, which is crystalline in structure. The argument is that the pointed edges can make microscopic abrasions and irritate the skin. Having said that, as the Dr. mentioned, this wouldn’t have an effect on the size of your pores, though it could be the source of Sally’s irritation (I’d also posit the guess that if Sally is sensitive, the “buffing” motion suggested for application by mineral makeup companies could cause further irritation- I know it has for me!)

By: Jessica Allison

Jessica Allison — Mon, 03 Oct 2011 18:38:10 +0000

Emily,

While the ingredients you listed are certainly beneficial to the skin, they’re in no way exclusive to mineral makeup.

As far as SPF goes, please consider that in the case of mineral makeup (or any other powder sunscreen), you’d have to wear about 1.2 grams on your face to get the SPF stated on the product’s label. To put that in perspective, you’d have to use about 1/6th of an ENTIRE JAR of your average mineral makeup every time you apply to get the correct coverage. The average woman applies only 0.085 grams at a time, so you’d have to put on 14 times the normal amount! Ick!

By: Emily frischhertz

Emily frischhertz — Fri, 09 Sep 2011 21:59:40 +0000

Would you say that these statements are true with regards to Jane Iredale Make-up? Which claims to have no fillers, no talc, no preservatives, no thylates and no other known carcinogens? It also claims to have hylaraunic acid, green tea extract, UVA/UVB protection, etc. All beneficial to the skin.

By: Constantine

Constantine — Sat, 20 Nov 2010 23:19:27 +0000

Dr. Benabio,

what about the articles found in pubmed, that show strong indications of titanium oxide nano and micro particles being possible carcinogenic when inhaled? What is your personal opinion on that? Are larger particles safe?

By: Bentonite,China Clay,Feldspar,Mica,Calcium Carbonate,Sepiolite,Lignite,Zeolite,Filter Aid

Tue, 05 Oct 2010 04:54:22 +0000

good post………………

By: asbestos surveys

asbestos surveys — Fri, 27 Aug 2010 07:18:13 +0000

Hello there, it’s a nice article!

By: Christy

Christy — Mon, 03 May 2010 20:40:23 +0000

I have used Bare Minerals about 4 yrs ago and it made my face break out ( i have combination skin with enlarged pores). It ended up in the trash can.

By: Lorraine

Lorraine — Sun, 02 May 2010 06:46:35 +0000

I have been using Bare Minerals for 4 years and I can say that my skin is clearer (I suffered terribly from acne during my teens, twenties, and well into my late 30′s, though less so of course). I also get comments (incredibly, after my acne nightmare…) that my skin is lovely and glowing! I do moisturize first (Olay Regenerist)AND use Clinique’s Pore Minimizer around my nose and on my chin, as I’ve found that mineral makeup can actually magnify pores instead of having the opposite effect which I believe BM claims. But other than that, I am totally happy with my Bare Minerals base. I also use their Warmth All-Over Face Color, which is much sheerer than a bronzer but gives a nice bronzy glow, and the Rare Minerals Blemish Therapy if I do have a breakout (much less frequently now, partly due to age- I’ll be 47 next week- and I believe partly due to the Bare Minerals). I guess I don’t have allergies to any of the potential irritants mentioned, so I think I’m lucky. I don’t think I’d ever wear liquid or cream base again. Any time I’ve tried- like for a special event or in a pinch- it feels so heavy and greasy and as if my skin is being smothered. So I guess I’m a mineral makeup convert!

By: Gilly

Gilly — Sat, 13 Mar 2010 14:21:10 +0000

Dr. Benabio,

I have sensitive eyes. I have been trying to find an undereye concealer but most cause a reaction after 4-5 hours. It’s a discomfort with some itchiness and irritation. I recently tried Jane Iredale which I thought was going to work– I seemed to be tolerating it better than some of the others — but didn’t.

Is there anything you can recommend? Some department store lines have not worked. Some drug store brands haven’t worked. I haven’t tried everything and am wondering if it might be the form it’s in. Should I avoid creams and look for a liquid. Could it be interacting with my undereye cream?

Thank you for any suggestions you may have.

By: Dr. Benabio

Dr. Benabio — Mon, 01 Mar 2010 00:24:14 +0000

@katia
I am sorry, I could not say which ingredients would be right for you. If you have concerns, then I recommend you bring the makeup to your physician and ask for his or her input. Thank you for the compliment.